The Christmas Charade

The Christmas Charade (2024) - Hallmark

Reviewed by L. Sue

The trailer for this movie is Christmas meets the FBI, and if you know me, you know I love me some spycraft mixed in with Jingle Bells. Whitney, a school librarian who always plays it safe, is looking for a little adventure. She starts her day by watching a spy show before heading to work. Kudos to her for waking up early enough to enjoy some TV—making me feel a bit better about choosing sleep over morning exercise or watching movies.

Whitney’s best friend convinces her to go on a blind date with "mark_loves_cats_1922," even personally vouching for him IRL. Despite some initial hesitation and even tossing the address into the trash, Whitney realizes she needs some excitement in her life and decides this date could be the perfect opportunity. She agrees to meet Mark at a restaurant—he’ll be the one wearing a green sweater. Plus, she’s slightly guilted into this as her parents want to set her up with some ophthalmologist. But before she counts Mark out, let's hear some details about this mystery man!

Picture this- It’s Christmas in a crowded restaurant, and nearly every guy is wearing a green sweater. Whitney mistakes Agent Josh Dawson for Mark and is confused when he starts asking questions about whether she read "the profile." Whitney is thinking of a dating profile, while Josh is thinking of a criminal rap sheet.

Josh, being a detective, soon realizes that Whitney isn’t the agent he was supposed to meet for a double date with the potential perp. Just as this realization dawns, the perp, Lou, and his wife, Patty, walk in. Whitney tries to leave, but Agent Dawson stops her, saying that leaving now would be extremely suspicious to Lou and Patty. It's just lunch, Dawson assures her, and after this, she can move on.

Whitney signed up for a small adventure, not dining with criminals! However, her need to do the right thing and a secret desire to catch the bad guy get her through the lunch. She babbles when nervous but makes enough of a good impression on Patty that she’s asked to help plan the big Mistletoe Ball on Christmas Eve.

Whitney wants to say no, and Agent Dawson wants her to refuse, but the big FBI boss greenlights this mission as it’s the closest the Bureau has gotten to Lou. It’s a great excuse to be near the object to be stolen—The Heart of Christmas, a necklace given to a German princess in the 1800s by an American industrialist heir.

Despite being a novice, Whitney proves to be a better undercover agent than Josh in some ways. She gets the perp to open up and is invited to help plan the big event. While Josh, a good agent cut from the lone wolf cloth, doesn’t always play well with others, Whitney listens to Patty and Lou, gaining their trust and in turn some valuable information.

At Lou and Patty’s home, Whitney and Patty are discussing the plans for the ball while Lou and "Johnnie" talk about a big potential investment. Patty lets it slip to Whitney that she hasn’t seen the necklace herself, but knows it’s stored in a secure vault and travels with its own security team. This is more intel than Josh manages to get out of Lou.

Whitney scores a second victory while at the museum venue for the ball. She notices a painting, and the museum guide reveals it’s a fake. This gives our adventure-seeking Whitney an idea: why not switch the real necklace with a fake one and then track it?

Josh, despite being a good agent, seems to be contributing little more than a badge to this operation and agrees to Whitney’s plan, having no better idea himself. They set off to get a fake necklace, crafted by Mrs. Claus herself. She wisely doesn’t ask too many questions about making costume jewelry from a crime scene photo, suggesting her Christmas store might be a front for a more lucrative business—albeit not completely “legit”.

Armed with the fake necklace, they set off to infiltrate the secure warehouse. Agent Dawson is clad in the FBI-mandated all-black attire, while Whitney sports an ugly Christmas sweater—probably an FBI first, and she's wearing it unironically.

During the vent-crawling scene, Whitney declares "Die Hard" the best Christmas movie. Feel free to weigh in, dear readers, if you agree or disagree. After all the planning and the use of gingerbread men to distract the guards (how hard was that gingerbread cookie that several guards didn't notice Whitney climbing down a rope?) Josh and Whitney make a dramatic getaway, swinging from building to building on a rope, all without gloves.

After all that Mission Impossibling they still don’t have the necklace. Whitney was close to grabbing it, but Josh pulled the plug as something didn’t feel right. To top it off, now Whitney and Josh have to spend December 23 with her parents because Whitney's best friend saw them at the Christmas/Jewelry shop and told her parents that Whitney has a boyfriend.

Josh and Whitney play holiday-themed Charades with her parents. Kudos to the movie for incorporating Charades in multiple ways! Her parents suspect that Whitney isn’t telling them everything, but they also realize that Josh is a decent person who genuinely cares for their daughter. Despite facing off with countless menacing criminals and dangerous in the field action, Josh was most nervous about this simple meeting of the parents—something he “just doesn’t do.” We are starting to feel bad for lone wolf Agent Dawson.

Fast forward to December 24, the day of the big ball, and it’s all come down to this: Whitney and Josh need to swap the necklace before it goes back to the vault and/or is stolen. Patty ropes Whitney into a tango, which she can actually do because she’s a former dancer, and she tells Josh to follow her lead. While they are dancing the tango, the necklace is stolen from Whitney’s purse. Oh no! What are they going to do?

As insurance, the baddies also grab Whitney’s parents—who snagged an invite after the Charades because “there too many unanswered questions from game night”—as hostages. Away the necklace and Whitney’s parents go in a black unmarked van. But there’s no need to panic. It turns out Whitney’s parents are former FBI agents, who now run their own home security company. They managed to subdue the kidnappers and, surprise—they were the ones who took the necklace once they realized what Whitney and Josh were up to.

Unlike in other movies, everyone here seems to be in the know—all except poor Whitney. And that’s the big twist in this movie: she feels betrayed, having been lied to by her parents her whole life, stifling her into making safe choices and not living life on her terms. Josh also gets some blame, as Whitney takes his frequent offers for her to back out as a sign he doesn’t believe she can do it. In reality, he was just looking out for her, realizing that this adventure was perhaps more than she had signed up for.

The henchmen and the museum director (the inside man) are led away for some serious interrogation. Meanwhile, Whitney heads directly to Patty’s house, realizing it was Patty behind all the robberies. There was a common theme among all the objects stolen—love. And no one loves love more than Patty! The necklace and the painting were just the latest additions to her growing collection. With the real perpetrator arrested, Whitney and Agent Dawson are free to sleigh off into the Christmas night. Yippee-ki-yay!


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Wrong Teacher

A Christmas Cookie Catastrophe

The Wrong Cheerleader